Eyewitness Accounts in a Violation of a Protective Order Case
Eyewitness accounts can be a crucial element of violation of a protective order cases and other California domestic violence prosecutions. Because of the intimate nature of domestic violence, most offenses occur outside the presence of witnesses. As a result, many intimate partner abuse cases are based on “he said, she said” allegations. Eyewitnesses, therefore, play a vital role in helping to prove or disprove that the accused violated his or her court order.
Protective orders can be issued against any intimate partner in a California domestic abuse case. Intimate partners may be straight or gay and can be married, divorced, cohabiting, have children together, or be currently or were formerly dating. Protective orders include orders issued by the court that prohibit the offender from engaging in specific acts of abuse, re-entering his or her own home or even behaving in a specified way.
Anyone who intentionally violates a protective order in a California domestic abuse case can be charged with a misdemeanor punishable by a maximum of one year in jail and a $1,000 fine. California courts may even punish an offender for violating an order in California that was issued in another state. If the violation results in physical injury to the alleged victim, the offender will serve mandatory jail time of at least 30 days and the fine may rise to $2,000.
An eyewitness’s job is to tell the judge and/or jury what he or she saw with no inherent bias. Easily said, but rarely done. Eyewitnesses almost always have a bias either for or against one of the parties, depending on his or her relationship with each. As a result, the truth generally gets lost in translation.
Because both attorneys have an equal opportunity to examine a witness, witnesses essentially testify for both parties. A skilled criminal defense lawyer knows how to take an eyewitness who is presented by the prosecution and turn him or her into a witness who ultimately helps prove the defendant’s version of the events. Similarly, a good defense attorney will invest time in preparing an eyewitness that he or she intends to “put on the stand” in order to try to make that witness as comfortable as possible with respect to answering questions from both lawyers.
Domestic abuse cases are usually based on a highly charged, emotional incident that unfortunately took a turn for the worse. This means that even if there was an eyewitness to the violation, that individual may not have witnessed all the events that led to the charged incident and may not have the accurate back-story on what took place before the charged incident. It is the attorney’s job to make sure that this type of information gets relayed to the jury. The experienced attorneys at The Kavinoky Law Firm have successfully defended countless individuals who were charged with violating protective orders. They are familiar with all aspects of California’s intimate partner violence laws and know how to skillfully examine witnesses in ways that are beneficial to their clients. In conjunction with their private investigators, the attorneys not only interview all witnesses but also check each witness’s criminal history to uncover any past conduct that could be considered relevant in weighing that witness’s credibility. A knowledgeable attorney will effectively cross-examine prosecution witnesses in the case to bring out and highlight discrepancies in their accounts that may otherwise be overlooked.
An eyewitness could potentially be the “kiss of death” to a defendant facing a domestic abuse charge. When charged with violating a court order (especially when there was an eyewitness), it becomes even more critical for the accused to hire an attorney who is experienced in witness preparation and who excels in cross-examination. The attorneys at The Kavinoky Law Firm know how to handle different witnesses under a variety of circumstances. Keeping the jury in mind, they know when it is appropriate to examine a witness with care and compassion and they know when it is appropriate to “take the gloves off” to aggressively attack. A skilled lawyer can outline an effective defense strategy during a free consultation.
